Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Producer
Responsibility: Where are We Now?
2
"What is producer responsibility?"
  • What is producer responsibility?
  • Extending a producer’s responsibility for a product to the post-consumer stage of a products life cycle (hence the phrase extended producer responsibility – producers already have some degree of responsibility for their products before they become discarded e.g. product liability)
  • Shifting responsibility upstream towards the producer and away from municipalities / local authorities
  • Providing incentives for producers to incorporate environmental considerations in the design of their products
3
"“Considering the life cycle..."
  • “Considering the life cycle of a product from manufacture until the end of its useful life, producers, material suppliers, trade, consumers and public authorities share specific waste management responsibilities. However it is the product manufacturer who has a predominant role since he takes key decisions concerning his product which largely determine its waste management potential.”


  • Extract from the
  • EU Community Strategy on Waste Management, 1996
4
"Producer responsibility is in effect..."
  • Producer responsibility is in effect a new policy tool for pollution prevention and waste / resource use minimisation usually translated into practice via legally enforceable product take back systems. It is characterised by e.g:
    • Responsibility placed on producers for take back of the product at the end-of-life stage (i.e. waste) including financial responsibility for the establishment and functioning of the take back schemes and for dealing with the end-of-life products
    • Bans on disposal to landfill / incineration; restrictions on utilisation of energy recovery
    • Targets for recovery / recycling of EOL products (usually with a high recycling quotient), with prescriptive conditions governing methods of treatment
    • Prescription of standards for minimum recycled content for new products
    • Reporting requirements, monitoring provisions and information disclosure
    • Bans / Phase out of hazardous substances and material bans & restrictions

5
"EU Producer Responsibility measures past"
  • EU Producer Responsibility measures past, present & future


  • Directive 94/62/EC on Packaging and Packaging Waste
  • Directive 91/157/EEC on Batteries and Accumulators
  • Directive  2000/53/EC on End of Life Vehicles
  • Proposed Directive on Waste from Electrical and Electronic Equipment


  • Supplemented by:
  • Directive 75/442/EEC on Waste (‘Framework Directive on Waste’)
  • Directive 91/689/EEC on Hazardous Waste
  • Directive 1999/31/EC on the Landfill of Waste (the ‘Landfill Directive’)
6
End-of-Life
7
"The End-of-Life Vehicles Directive"
  • The End-of-Life Vehicles Directive


  • Article 4 – ban on hazardous substances / materials – lead; mercury; cadmium; hexavalent chromium – post 1 July 2003. Subject to certain conditional exemptions in Annex II
  • Article 5 – economic operators to set up collection systems; ELVs to be transferred to authorised treatment facilities at no cost to the last holder / owner; producers to meet all or a significant part of the costs
  • Article 6 – stipulations on storage and treatment methods for ELVs
  • Article 7 – requirements and targets for re-use and recovery (with a preference for recycling)
  • By 2006 85% minimum by an average weight per vehicle and year must be reused or recovered – 80% minimum by an average weight per vehicle and year must be reused or recycled (i.e. = permitted maximum of 5% e.g. energy recovery); for pre-1980 vehicles the figures are 75% and 70% respectively
  • From 2015 it will be 95% reuse and recovery – 85% reused or recycled
  • Type approval requirements to be amended so that conditions as to minimum levels of re-usability, recyclability and recoverability are imposed
8
UK progress so far?
9
The Government’s Position?
10
WEEE
11
Proposed WEEE Directive
  • Producers:
  • Financially responsible for:
  • - transport from collection facilities
  • - treatment, recovery, disposal
  • Originally a 5 year delay in financial responsibility
  • New products: Collective or individual systems permitted
  • “Historic” products: Collective systems only
  • Distributors/retailers:
  • Must take back EOL product
    when selling similar new product.
12
Proposed WEEE Directive
  • Original Target for collection from households (non-binding):
  • - 4 kg/inhabitant/year
  • Recovery Targets:   Total   Material
  • Large Appliances      80       75
  • Small Appliances      60       50
  • Consumer Equipment  60       50
  • Tools      60       50
  • Toys      60       50
  • IT and Telecom      75       65
  • Gas Discharge Lamps  ---       80
  • CRTs                            75       70
13
Proposed ROS Directive
  • Substance ‘substitutions’
  • - lead
  • - mercury
  • - cadmium
  • - hexavalent chromium
  • - 2 brominated flame retardants  (PBB and PBDE)


  • 1 January 2008 - original phase out date
14
Proposed ROS Directive
  • Exemptions:
  • - If no substitute,
  • - If substitute is worse for the environment or health
  • - Maximum concentration levels may be allowed for
  •    specific materials / components.
15
What has happened so far?
16
European Parliament Amendments
17
European Parliament Amendments
18
European Parliament Amendments
19
 Timetable / Timescale?
20
Packaging
21
"Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging..."
  • Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Regulations 1997 (as amended)
  • Affects businesses which:
  • Perform one or more of these activities
    • Manufacturing packaging raw materials
    • Converting materials into packaging
    • Using packaging to pack products or for filling with products
    • Selling packaging (i.e. products contained in packaging) to the final consumer; and
  • Own the packaging in question; and
  • Supply to someone in another stage of the packaging chain or to the final user, and
  • Exceed the threshold tests in the previous year i.e.
    • Annual turnover exceeds £2 million and
    • Handles more than 50 tonnes of packaging for the year in question
22
"Recovery and Recycling Targets:"
  • Recovery and Recycling Targets:


  • Overall recovery and recycling targets are set for obligated businesses as a whole, e.g.


  • Year Recovery Recycling


  • 2000 45% of packaging 13% of packaging


  • 2001 56% of packaging 18% of packaging


  • 2002 59% of packaging 19% of packaging
23
"However,"
  • However, businesses bear responsibility for meeting these targets in different proportions according to which activity they perform (= the “activity obligation”):


      • Manufacturing packaging raw materials – 6%
      • Converting materials into packaging – 9%
      • Using packaging to pack products or for filling with products – 37%
      • Selling packaging (i.e. products contained in packaging) to the final consumer – 48%

24
"Recovery and Recycling Obligations"
  • Recovery and Recycling Obligations


  • The individual recovery and recycling obligations will depend upon the activity in question and the type of packaging material being handled:


  • Recovery obligation = packaging handled x activity obligation (i.e. % share) x recovery target
    • NB. Recovery means either recycling, energy recovery or composting
  • Recycling obligation = packaging handled by material x activity obligation x recycling target
    • NB. Recycling means reprocessing waste materials in a production process into new materials or product
  • In addition, producers who are “sellers” have an obligation to provide certain information to consumers
25
"Compliance"
  • Compliance


  • There are 2 ways in which a business can meet its obligations:
  • Comply individually (note: a business with an annual turnover exceeding £5 million must submit a ‘compliance plan’ with its application for registration setting out the steps it will take to comply. In addition the business must pay the registration fee to the Agency, provide data on packaging handled, recovered and recycled each year and provide evidence of compliance with the recovery and recycling obligations.
  • Join a compliance scheme – there are various scheme in operation including VALPAK, BIFFPACK, CLEANAPACK and RECYCLE UK. Here, provided the business meets the conditions of scheme membership, including provision of necessary data and payment of subscription fees, the scheme assumes the compliance obligations of its members
26
"Packaging Recovery Notes"
  • Packaging Recovery Notes



  • The system of Packaging Recovery Notes (“PRNs”) has been developed in the UK – and is unique to the UK; no other EU country chose this route to implementing the EU Directive – as a means of enabling obligated businesses and compliance schemes to obtain evidence of compliance.


  • PRNs are issued by accredited packaging waste reprocessors. Obligated businesses / compliance schemes delivering packaging waste to a reprocessor can ask to be issued with a PRN for the requisite amount. Alternatively they can buy PRNs from reprocessors or on the open market from those with excess PRNs on their hands (they are tradeable).
27
"Essential Requirements"
  • Essential Requirements


  • The Packaging (Essential Requirements) Regulations 1998 translate into UK law the requirement of the EU Packaging Directive that, primarily, all packaging in the EU must comply with certain “essential requirements” in order to ensure uniformity across the EU Single Market.


  • No one responsible for packing or filling products into packaging or importing packed or filled packaging into the UK may place that packaging on the market unless that packaging fulfils the Essential Requirements and the Heavy Metal Concentration Limits:
28
"In summary,"
  • In summary, the Essential Requirements are:
  • Packaging must be minimal subject to safety, hygiene and acceptance for the packed product and for the consumer
  • Noxious or hazardous substances in packaging must be minimised in emissions, ash or leachate from incineration or landfill
  • Packaging must be recoverable through at least one of:
    • Material recycling
    • Incineration with energy recovery
    • Composting
    • Biodegradation
  • In summary, the Heavy Metal Limits are:
  • Aggregate heavy metal limits apply to cadmium, mercury, lead and hexavalent chromium. The total by weight should not exceed:
  • 600 ppm on or after 30 June 1998
  • 250 ppm on or after 30 June 1999
  • 100 ppm on or after 30 June 2001
29
 
30